- The Productive Disruptive
- Posts
- When the story changes what came before
When the story changes what came before
Every Tuesday, The Productive Disruptive delivers storytelling science, message makeovers, cultural commentary, and a little rebellious hope for anyone still stubborn enough to believe communication can change the world.
Dorian Johnson
September 15, 2026
Did a wise PHriend forward this to you? [Subscribe here.]
There's a certain type of story that really is a noodle-scratcher… Where you reflect and go:
“Damn, that means something totally different now.”
Presenting a contamination narrative…
In narrative psychology, contamination describes a story in which something positive is followed by something negative, and what comes later spoils, undermines, or changes the meaning of what came before.
A contamination narrative isn’t simply:
Good thing? Yay!
Then bad thing? Boooo.
The turn fundamentally changes how we understood the good thing.
Take Love Canal
Love Canal was once supposed to represent possibility.
The area began with plans for a “model city.”
Eventually, families bought homes there. Children attended school there. People built ordinary lives in what they thought was an ordinary neighborhood.
Then residents began discovering what was underneath them.
Buffalo News
Thousands of tons of chemical waste had been buried in the area.
Chemicals began appearing in yards, basements, soil, and water.
Residents raised concerns about their health and their children’s health. Love Canal eventually became a national symbol of hazardous waste and helped fuel public pressure that drove environmental change.
Look at what happened to the meaning of home.
Before the discovery, home could mean safety, stability, investment, family.
Afterward, home could also mean exposure.
That’s contamination.
And for people trying to communicate about public health, justice, or social change, that structure can be incredibly useful because sometimes the most important part of a story is the moment when new information changes the picture.
We’re seeing versions of that constantly.
A technology, like AI, is exciting until its costs become clearer.
A product feels convenient until we better understand its effects.
The storyteller’s job here isn’t to scold people for what they believed before.
It’s to make the turn understandable.
Try this four-part lens:
Spot the good.
What does the audience initially understand as safe, successful, admirable, promising, or normal?
Find the turn.
What happens that disrupts that understanding?
Name what changed.
What does the audience have to reinterpret now?
Decide where the feeling goes.
What should people be able to question, demand, support, redesign, or do with what they now know?
Contamination stories can create anger, grief, betrayal, or outrage.
They can also drift into fatalism if the message becomes, “Everything is terrible, everything is rigged, good luck out there.”
Give people somewhere to put the feeling.
Sometimes a first step toward changing narrative is telling a story that makes the old version impossible to see the same way again.
🧠 Story Science Side Note: Stories do more than just report events, they organize them into meaning.
Contamination narratives do that by changing how we interpret what came before.
In the research, people make choices about which events to include, how to frame what led up to them and what followed, and what conclusions to draw.
📝 Message Makeover:
Before:
Residents were exposed to hazardous chemicals.
After:
Families bought homes believing they were building safe, stable lives there. Then they learned chemical waste had been buried beneath the neighborhood.
The first version gives us the harm.
The second gives us what was valued before the harm changed its meaning.
🛠️ The PHacilitator’s Corner:
Are you starting too late?
If your story begins with harm, the audience may understand the problem already.
But what happens if you show them what existed before the harm changed it?
For example
Instead of:
“AI has environmental costs.”
Ask:
What promise made people excited about it in the first place?
Sometimes the contrast is where the story wakes it up.
Sayonara!