What Does A Choice Cost?

Every Tuesday, The Productive Disruptive delivers storytelling science, message makeovers, cultural commentary, and a little rebellious hope for anyone still stubborn enough to believe communication can change the world.

Did a wise PHriend forward this to you? [Subscribe here.]

I was listening to an audiobook when somebody described feeling like Neo, wishing he’d never taken the red pill.

You know the scene.

Morpheus holds out two pills. Blue takes you back to the life you know. Red shows you what’s really going on.

Now imagine Neo takes the blue pill.

He wakes up and goes to work, and unless he was trying to use Outlook on Nov 12(HA😂), same ol sa’ same ol’.

Anywho…

Morpheus interrupts that routine by offering Neo a choice.

Neo wants to know what’s really going on. He also has a whole life he could go back to. That pull in two directions is the conflict.

Now let’s tag in conflict’s overlooked cousin, stakes. What could Neo lose either way?

If Neo chooses…

He gives up…

🔵 Blue. Go back to the life he knows.

His shot at the truth.

🔴 Red. Find out what’s really going on.

The life he knows.

🧠 Story Science Side Note: 

In a series of experiments, psychologists Amos Tversky and Eldar Shafir found that when options were harder to choose between, people were more likely to put off the decision or look for another option.

When you tell the story, show readers what each option could cost.

https://journals.sagepub.com/doi/10.1111/j.1467-9280.1992.tb00047.x

In a public health story, you can make those stakes visible in one sentence.

📝 Message Makeover:

Before

“Families with limited incomes face financial barriers to getting their prescriptions.”

After

“For some families, paying the rent means putting off a prescription refill.”

Now you can picture what the family is weighing. Rent is due. So is the refill.

And that’s not to mention there’s food to buy and places to be with their associated costs.

Why spell out the stakes?

When we tell these stories, we shape what people see as the problem. Show the rent and the refill side by side, and policy questions may come into focus. What could change so families can afford both?

🛠️ The PHacilitator’s Corner:

Pull one sentence from a draft where you say people face barriers. Ask yourself:

  • Conflict. What are they trying to do, and what’s getting in the way?

  • Choice. What options are actually available to them?

  • Stakes. What could each option cost them?

Now rewrite that one sentence so readers can see the trade-off. If you are stewarding someone's story, ask them which options they actually had and what was on the line.

One last thing. 

People make the best calls they can with the options they have. Inequity can take options off the table before anyone gets to choose. If a family is trying to stay housed and keep up with their meds, the question I want us asking is: what would have to change so they could do both?

How’d I Do?