- The Productive Disruptive
- Posts
- The story that never happened
The story that never happened
Every Tuesday, The Productive Disruptive delivers storytelling science, message makeovers, cultural commentary, and a little rebellious hope for anyone still stubborn enough to believe communication can change the world.
Did a wise PHriend forward this to you? [Subscribe here.]

Homer Simpson tries to fix a toaster and accidentally invents time travel.

It sends him back to the Mesozoic Era (yeah, we talkin dinosaurs).
While there, he squashes a bug, and when he gets transported back, he comes home to find out Ned Flanders runs the world.
Yeah, the Diddly guy.

The fun is watching him change one thing, then waiting to see what he comes home to.
(Shout-out to Ray Bradbury’s A Sound of Thunder. I loved that man’s writing.)
Now imagine all we got was the ending.
Ned Flanders runs the world.
You might ask, How’d we get here?
Here’s another common ending in the real world.
A patient misses their appointment.
It’s 5:30 PM. The exam room chair is empty, and the clinic marks the 5:15 appointment as a no-show.
That very morning, the patient texted back to confirm they’d make it.
But what happened?
At 4:45, the last bus that could get them there on time pulled away. They knew the route. They’d taken it before.
But leaving work before five meant losing pay they couldn’t afford to lose.
If you could rewind that afternoon and change one thing, what would you change? What might happen differently?
I’d ask that in a room full of people and give everybody a minute. I’m curious whether we’d all rewind to the same moment.
My behavior change brain goes to opportunity, the O in COM-B.
The model looks at what it takes for a behavior (B) to happen. Capability (C) is whether you have the skills or ability to do it. Opportunity (O) is whether your circumstances make it possible. Motivation (M) is what drives you to do it, from goals to habits.
I’d rewind to 4:45, when the bus pulled away, and they were still on the clock. You might’ve picked a different moment.
Either way, we started with the same ending: an empty chair at 5:30. Now we’re each imagining an afternoon that never happened.
The next time a story like this gets told, what if we include the 4:45 bus? Now the reader can see what the patient was up against before that chair ever sat empty.
🧠 Story Science Side Note:
That’s counterfactual thinking: imagining how something that already happened might have gone differently.
In one traffic safety experiment, changes in attitudes stuck around when people came up with the alternate version themselves.
📝 Message Makeover:
Before
“Why didn’t they show up?”
After
“What would’ve had to change for them to make it?”
🛠️ The PHacilitator’s Corner:
1. Rewind one moment. Think of something that didn’t go the way you hoped. Maybe a conversation got tense, a meeting ran long, or fewer people showed up than you expected. What was the first reason you gave yourself for why it went that way? Write it down. Then replay what happened right before things went sideways.
2. Change one condition. As you replay that moment, pick one thing you wish had gone differently. Write down that one change. Leave the rest of the scene as it was.
3. Ask what might have happened. Play the scene forward with that one change. Then look back at the first reason you wrote down. Does it still explain what happened? What would you try next time?
Forever in sleep debt ✌🏾